If you're managing a fleet or haulage operation, you've probably heard about Transport Management Systems (TMS); software designed to streamline everything from route planning to freight audits. But is switching from spreadsheets and manual processes really worth it?

Let’s break down the advantages and disadvantages of adopting a TMS and see how it stacks up against old-school methods.

‍

The Downsides of Manual Processes & Spreadsheets

‍

Time-Consuming & Prone to Errors
Manually tracking runs, fuel costs, and driver hours in spreadsheets is tedious. A single typo can lead to incorrect invoices, missed deliveries, or compliance issues.

Lack of Real-Time Visibility
Spreadsheets don’t update themselves. If a driver faces a delay, you won’t know until they call in, meaning reactive (and often costly) decisions.

Inefficient Route Planning
Optimizing routes manually is guesswork at best. You could be wasting fuel and hours on suboptimal journeys that cost you more than they're worth.

Compliance Risks
Keeping up with driver hours, vehicle maintenance, and industry regulations manually is risky. Missed checks can lead to fines or worse.

Scaling Becomes Impossible
As your fleet grows, the admin needed to stay on top of it all becomes insurmountable. More trucks = more tabs, more compliance, more formulas, and more headaches.

‍

The Benefits of a Transport Management System (TMS)

A TMS like Stratum automates the heavy lifting, but it’s not just about replacing spreadsheets, it’s about working smarter with a system designed around you.

‍

Smarter dispatch & Scheduling

Manage your jobs from one central dashboard. Streamline administration with automatic import of information, and drag and drop resource allocation. Create job templates and invoice a days runs in one click.

Automated Invoicing & Billing

Never let work pile up. Track PODs, handovers, interchanges and weights in real time. Generate accurate and professional invoices in seconds and stop sweating the small stuff. Fewer errors, faster payments.

See Real-time Margins and Uncover your Costs

Keep a pulse on your profits and protect your margins. Know your return on a job before it happens and plan with your bottom line in mind. Understand where your resources are allocated, from fuel to maintenance, and start making smarter decisions.

Compliance Made Easy

With Stratum, you get a central hub where all your fleet and driver documents live. Things like service records, tax certs, insurance policies, CPCs, et cetera. The system keeps an eye on expiry dates and sends you automatic reminders when something’s due. No more digging through spreadsheets or missing a renewal. It’s all handled, so you can focus on keeping your fleet moving.

Data You Can Actually Use
Instead of static spreadsheets, a TMS gives real analytics: spot trends, track KPIs, and make decisions backed by data. Stratum’s reporting tools help you identify inefficiencies and opportunities for growth.

‍

The (Potential) Drawbacks of a TMS

No system is perfect, so let’s be realistic:

Upfront Cost & Learning Curve
There’s an initial investment (though many TMS providers offer scalable pricing). Your team will need training, which is why starting with Stratum means 1 to 1 traning sessions and access to our library of tutorials, guides and videos. Once they’re on board, efficiency skyrockets.

Operational Disruption During Setup
Implementing a TMS can temporarily disrupt workflows. That’s why Stratum offers dedicated onboarding support, with full data import and training to minimise downtime.

Not All TMS Solutions Are Equal
Some systems are overloaded with features you’ll never use. The key is finding one that fits your needs—like Stratum, which focuses on user-friendly, practical tools without unnecessary complexity.

‍

Final Thoughts

Switching from manual processes to a TMS isn’t just a tech upgrade - it’s a strategic move. For transport and logistics companies in the UK and Ireland, Stratum offers a tailored, scalable solution that grows with your business. Whether you're managing a small fleet or a national operation, the right TMS can transform your efficiency, compliance, and bottom line.

Ready to ditch the spreadsheets?
Contact us to learn how Stratum can streamline your logistics operations.

‍

‍